Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time [Season 1 Episode 11]

Review: Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time – Season 1, Episode 11

A Surprisingly Entertaining Isekai with a Twist

If you’re tired of the same old isekai tropes—heroes summoned to save the world, overpowered protagonists with zero personality, or harems that make no sense—Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time might just be the breath of fresh air you didn’t know you needed. Episode 11, in particular, takes the series in a direction that’s both ridiculous and oddly compelling, proving that sometimes, the most absurd premises can be the most fun.

The Plot So Far

For those who haven’t been keeping up, the story follows Takumi Iruma, a salaryman who gets accidentally summoned to another world alongside a group of actual heroes. As compensation for the mix-up, a goddess grants him the ability to choose any skill he wants. Instead of picking something flashy like sword mastery or fire magic, Takumi opts for alchemy—a seemingly boring choice that turns out to be ridiculously overpowered.

By Episode 11, Takumi has already established himself as a force to be reckoned with, using his alchemy to create everything from high-quality weapons to… well, toilets (yes, you read that right). The episode focuses on Takumi preparing for the looming threat of Sidonia, a kingdom that seems to have a bizarre obsession with his inventions. Meanwhile, his growing entourage—including a spider-girl familiar, an elf slave-turned-companion, and a maid with questionable armor—continues to expand in the most chaotic way possible.

What Fans Are Saying

The online discourse around this episode is a mix of exasperation and reluctant enjoyment. Here’s what stands out:

1. “Why Is This So Addictive?”
   A common sentiment among fans is that the show shouldn’t be as entertaining as it is. One Reddit user put it perfectly: “I keep rolling my eyes, but I can’t stop watching.” The absurdity of Takumi’s inventions (toilets as a world-changing commodity? Really?) and the show’s self-awareness make it hard to look away.

2. The Slave Debate
   The show’s handling of slavery has been a point of contention. Some viewers find it uncomfortable, especially when Takumi casually suggests slavery as a way to keep his inventions secret. Others argue that the show at least tries to justify it with “they’re treated nicely!”—though that’s not exactly a great defense.

3. The Armor Controversy
   Fans can’t decide whether Takumi’s “armor” designs are hilarious or just plain lazy. One MyAnimeList commenter pointed out: “The elf’s ‘armor’ is basically a metal bra, and the maid’s looks like a frilly dress. At least own up to the fanservice!”

4. The Side Characters Steal the Show
   While Takumi is the protagonist, the supporting cast—especially the spider-girl Maple and the tsundere elf Sofia—are getting more love. One fan joked: “Maple’s design is nightmare fuel, but I’d die for her.”

Final Thoughts

Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time isn’t trying to be high art, and that’s okay. Episode 11 leans into the ridiculousness with confidence, delivering a mix of action, comedy, and questionable world-building choices. If you’re looking for a show that doesn’t take itself too seriously but still manages to be oddly engaging, this might just be your next guilty pleasure.

Rating: 7.5/10 – Flawed but fun, with just enough charm to keep you coming back.

Now, if only they’d stop with the stat screens…