Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time [Season 1 Episode 1 to Episode 12]

“Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time” – A Surprisingly Fun Isekai Ride

When it comes to isekai anime, the genre is so saturated that it’s hard to find something that stands out. Yet, Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time manages to carve its own niche—albeit with some familiar tropes—by focusing on a protagonist who just wants a quiet life but ends up becoming ridiculously overpowered anyway.

The Premise: A Salaryman’s Accidental Adventure

The show follows Takumi Iruma, a salaryman who gets accidentally summoned to another world alongside a group of actual heroes. As compensation for the mix-up, a goddess grants him the ability to choose any skill he wants. Hoping for a peaceful existence, he picks alchemy—only to realize it’s far more broken than he ever imagined.

From the get-go, the premise is a mix of The Rising of the Shield Hero and That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime, but with a twist: Takumi isn’t interested in fighting or glory. He just wants to live comfortably, which leads to some hilarious and unexpected consequences.

What Fans Are Saying

The online discourse around this anime is a rollercoaster. Some viewers love it for its self-awareness and humor, while others groan at the overused tropes. Here’s a breakdown of the fan reactions:

1. “Another OP Isekai MC? Yawn.”
   A common complaint is that Takumi falls into the “overpowered protagonist” category way too quickly. One MyAnimeList user pointed out:

   “First episode wasn’t horrible, but the MC is such a Marty Stu so far.”

Others echoed this sentiment, especially with the frequent stat screens and game-like mechanics. One fan joked:

“Anybody know if this is going to keep throwing up stat screens every two minutes? Because while some people like that sort of thing, I personally find it extremely lazy writing.”

1. “But It’s Weirdly Entertaining?”
   Despite the criticisms, many admitted they couldn’t stop watching. The show’s charm lies in its absurdity—like Takumi casually revolutionizing sanitation in a medieval world by inventing toilets. One fan hilariously noted:

   “And here we thought the one where he uses slimes to open a laundromat is stupid. Now we have ‘Making Toilets In Another World With My Slave Girls.'”

The humor is hit-or-miss, but when it lands, it’s gold.

1. “The Slave Girl Trope Needs to Die”
   A major point of contention is the show’s handling of slavery. While Takumi treats his “servants” well, the narrative still romanticizes the concept. One fan sarcastically remarked:

   “No no, see, the slavery is okay because we treat them nicely.”

Others were more forgiving, arguing that it’s just a fantasy trope—but it’s definitely a divisive element.

1. “The Animation and World-Building Are Surprisingly Good”
   Despite the generic premise, the animation quality and world-building have won over some skeptics. The alchemy scenes are visually impressive, and the supporting cast—like Takumi’s spider familiar, Maple—adds a lot of personality. One viewer praised:

   “Enjoying this more than I should—it’s bad but gets an ‘A’ for effort.”

Final Verdict: A Guilty Pleasure

Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time isn’t groundbreaking, but it’s a fun, mindless watch for isekai fans. It leans into its tropes with enough self-awareness to keep things entertaining, even if it occasionally stumbles into cringe territory.

If you’re looking for a show with an OP protagonist, quirky side characters, and a mix of humor and action, this one’s worth a shot. Just don’t expect deep storytelling—sometimes, a little absurdity is all you need.

Rating: 7/10 – Flawed but Fun

What do you think? Love it or hate it? Drop your thoughts in the comments!