Magic Maker Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata [Season 1 Episode 1 to Episode 12]

Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata – A Wholesome Yet Controversial Start

Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata (or Magic Maker: How to Make Magic in Another World) is the latest addition to the ever-growing isekai genre, and it’s already sparking heated discussions among fans. The anime, produced by Studio DEEN and airing in Winter 2025, follows Shion, a 30-year-old man who dies and is reborn as a child in a medieval fantasy world where magic doesn’t exist—or so everyone thinks.

From the first episode, the show sets itself apart by focusing not just on Shion’s journey but also on his relationship with his older sister, Marie. This dynamic has become the center of debate, with some praising its heartwarming sibling bond and others… well, let’s just say they’re side-eyeing the implications.

The Premise: A Twist on the Isekai Formula

Unlike most isekai protagonists who wake up in another world with overpowered abilities, Shion starts from scratch—literally. Reborn as a baby, he grows up in a noble family alongside Marie, who becomes his caretaker and closest companion. The twist? Magic doesn’t exist in this world—until Shion discovers it through an unexpected source: emotions.

Fans have mixed feelings about this setup. Some appreciate the fresh take, like one Reddit user who said:

“Starting the show from the perspective of the sister instead of the reincarnated MC was a smart move. It makes the world feel more grounded, and Marie’s protectiveness over Shion is adorable.”

Others, however, find the execution questionable. A MyAnimeList commenter pointed out:

“A 30-year-old man in a child’s body declaring he’ll never marry so he can stay with his sister? Yeah, no. That’s not wholesome—that’s creepy.”

The show walks a fine line between innocent sibling love and… something far less innocent, and viewers are divided on whether it’s intentional or just clumsy writing.

The Controversy: Magic, Emotions, and… Incest?

The biggest point of contention is how magic is introduced. In the first episode, Shion witnesses glowing orbs of energy when fish mate—and later, similar energy appears when he hugs Marie. This has led to wild theories (and memes) about the nature of magic in this world.

Some fans are already dreading where this might lead:

“Magic through incest? Bro, are you for real? If this turns into some weird romance, I’m dropping it faster than a hot potato.”

Others argue that the show is being unfairly judged:

“They’re just kids expressing innocent love. Not everything has to be sexualized. Let the story develop before jumping to conclusions.”

The debate rages on, but one thing’s clear: Magic Maker has managed to grab attention—for better or worse.

Animation and Pacing: A Mixed Bag

Visually, the anime is decent but not groundbreaking. The character designs are cute, especially Marie, who’s already a fan favorite. However, some viewers have criticized the unnatural dialogue:

“Why do these kids talk like adults? A 6-year-old shouldn’t sound like a philosophy professor.”

The pacing has also been called slow, with one fan noting:

“The first episode didn’t do much besides set up the sibling dynamic. I’ll give it a few more episodes, but it needs to pick up soon.”

Still, the opening and ending themes have been well-received, adding some charm to an otherwise divisive start.

Final Verdict: Potential or Problematic?

Magic Maker has all the ingredients of a classic isekai—reincarnation, fantasy, and a protagonist with a unique goal. But its reliance on sibling dynamics as a plot device has overshadowed its potential.

Will it evolve into a heartwarming adventure about creating magic from scratch? Or will it devolve into the very tropes fans are dreading? Only time will tell.

For now, if you’re into unconventional isekai with a side of controversy, Magic Maker might be worth checking out. Just… maybe keep your expectations in check.

Rating (so far): ★★★☆☆ (3/5) – Promising but polarizing.

What do you think? Is Magic Maker a hidden gem or a disaster waiting to happen? Drop your thoughts in the comments!