Kuroshitsuji: Midori no Majo-hen [Season 5 Episode 2]

“Kuroshitsuji: Midori no Majo-hen” – A Darkly Enchanting Return to Form (Episode 2 Review)

The latest season of Kuroshitsuji (Black Butler), titled Midori no Majo-hen (Emerald Witch Arc), has finally graced our screens, and Episode 2 does not disappoint. Produced by CloverWorks, this season continues the eerie, gothic charm that fans have come to love, blending supernatural mystery with the signature dark humor of the franchise. Set in 19th-century Germany, the story follows Ciel Phantomhive and his demon butler, Sebastian, as they investigate a series of mysterious deaths linked to the infamous “Werewolf Forest.”

A Feast for the Eyes (and Ears)

One of the first things fans noticed—and raved about—was the stunning animation quality. From the fluidity of Sebastian’s tea-pouring (seriously, that scene was ultra HD 4K levels of gorgeous) to the hauntingly beautiful depictions of the Emerald Witch’s lore, the visuals are a treat. The opening and ending themes, both clocking in at two minutes long, have also been a hot topic. Fans are loving the “banger” songs and visuals, with many praising the effort put into making them stand out.

Language Barriers and Confusion

One of the more divisive aspects of this episode was the handling of multiple languages. The story involves characters speaking German, Japanese, and English, which led to some confusion among viewers. As one fan pointed out, “Because everything is in Japanese, it wasn’t always clear what language was being spoken and who could understand who.” This was especially noticeable during conversations between the witch, Sieglinde Sullivan, and Sebastian, where German was supposedly being spoken but sounded like Japanese to the untrained ear. Some fans were disappointed that the anime didn’t lean harder into authentic German dialogue, while others appreciated the effort despite the occasional butchering of pronunciation.

Humor and Misunderstandings

The episode wasn’t all doom and gloom—far from it. Sieglinde’s antics provided plenty of laughs, particularly her wildly incorrect assumptions about Ciel and Sebastian’s relationship. One fan hilariously noted, “Damn, was this girl either horny or completely misunderstanding the situation? ROFLMAO.” Her sheltered upbringing led to some awkward (and downright hilarious) moments, like when she touched Ciel’s “weenie” (yes, that happened). Sebastian’s barely contained amusement at her antics was a highlight, proving that even a demon butler can’t resist a good laugh.

The Mystery Deepens

The plot is thickening nicely, with the reveal that the villagers’ deaths are linked to poisonous flowers. But the real intrigue lies in the werewolf mystery and the eerie miasma surrounding the forest. The episode’s climax, featuring a rare emotional moment from Sebastian (yes, Sebastian crying—something no one saw coming), has fans buzzing. “Seeing Sebastian cry wasn’t on my bingo list, lmaoo,” one viewer quipped. The tears, likely tied to the supernatural forces at play, have sparked theories about what’s really lurking in the mist.

Fan Reactions: A Mixed Bag (But Mostly Love)

The general consensus? This episode was a hit. Fans are loving the creepy atmosphere of the village, the animation quality, and the way the story is unfolding. One fan gushed, “This is my favorite arc in the manga, and it looks like it’ll be the same in the anime. Everything is so good—not even the language mix-up can upset me.” Others are already declaring Sieglinde an “icon” for her over-the-top personality and stunning character design.

That said, some viewers are still scratching their heads over certain details, like the village’s all-female population and the origins of the Emerald Witch’s lineage. “If the village is all women, what is the family tree of the Emerald Witch?” one fan pondered. These questions are likely to be answered as the arc progresses, but for now, they’re adding to the intrigue.

Final Thoughts

Episode 2 of Kuroshitsuji: Midori no Majo-hen delivers everything fans could want: stunning animation, a gripping mystery, laugh-out-loud moments, and even a few unexpected tears. While the language barrier might trip up some viewers, the overall execution is solid, and the story is shaping up to be one of the strongest arcs in the series.

If you’re a fan of dark fantasy with a side of humor, this season is a must-watch. And if you’re not already hooked, just wait—things are only going to get wilder from here.

Rating: 9/10 – A near-perfect blend of mystery, humor, and gothic charm.

What did you think of the episode? Drop your theories (or favorite Sieglinde moments) in the comments!