Kuroshitsuji (Black Butler) [Season 5 Episode 2]

Black Butler Season 5 Episode 2: A Devilishly Good Time

If you’re a fan of Black Butler, you already know that Ciel Phantomhive and his demon butler, Sebastian Michaelis, never fail to deliver a mix of dark humor, intrigue, and jaw-dropping elegance. Season 5, Episode 2, titled “His Butler, Alarmed,” is no exception. With its release on April 12, 2025, this episode has already sparked a whirlwind of reactions from fans—ranging from excitement over Sebastian’s flawless butler skills to heated debates about the new characters and their motives.

The Plot Thickens

The episode picks up with Ciel and Sebastian settling into Weston College, where Ciel has taken on the role of a dormitory warden. The dynamic duo faces immediate challenges, including a werewolf sighting and the introduction of Sieglinde Sullivan, whose identity revelation has left fans buzzing. Meanwhile, the return of fan-favorite characters like Soma (riding in on an elephant, no less!) has injected a dose of nostalgia and chaos into the story.

One of the standout moments is Ciel’s confrontation with Maurice Cole, a rival student whose deceptive nature has already made him a prime target for Phantomhive-style revenge. Fans are eagerly anticipating Cole’s downfall, with comments like “You don’t mess with Ciel and walk away like nothing happened” flooding discussion boards.

Sebastian Steals the Show (Again)

As always, Sebastian’s effortless grace and terrifying efficiency are highlights of the episode. Whether he’s completing impossible tasks for Ciel or casually flirting with danger (and possibly a kid in the library—more on that later), fans can’t get enough of him. One MyAnimeList user summed it up perfectly: “Sebastian still as elegant as ever in this episode, making everything look easy.”

However, not all moments were universally praised. A controversial scene where Sebastian seems to cross boundaries with a younger character sparked mixed reactions. Some fans brushed it off as typical demon antics, while others found it unsettling. “Wtf was that scene where Sebastian seemed to be flirting with a kid in the library??? Calm down,” one user wrote.

The Return of Soma and the Nostalgia Factor

Soma’s grand entrance—complete with an elephant—was a crowd-pleaser, with fans flooding threads with all-caps excitement (“SOMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA”). His return brings a lighter tone to the otherwise tense atmosphere, and his dynamic with Ciel and Sebastian remains as entertaining as ever.

The episode also leans into the series’ signature blend of Victorian aesthetics and supernatural intrigue. From the elaborate school hierarchy to the eerie werewolf subplot, Black Butler continues to balance its gothic roots with fresh storytelling.

Fan Reactions: Love, Hate, and Everything In Between

The MyAnimeList discussion thread for this episode is a goldmine of passionate takes. Here’s a quick rundown of what fans are saying:

• On Ciel’s Revenge: “I can’t wait for Ciel to make [Cole’s] life hell.” Fans are living for the moment when Ciel turns the tables on his rivals.
• On Animation and Sound: “This one feels like they had more time to put some real artistry in the mix.” Many praised the updated visuals and foley work.
• On the Confessional Scene: “The fanservice we all got blessed with!! 10/10.” Sebastian’s role as a demon-priest hybrid was a highlight for some.
• On the New Characters: “Cole seems annoying.” Not everyone is a fan of the new antagonists, but they’re undeniably effective at stirring the pot.

Final Thoughts

Black Butler Season 5, Episode 2 is a solid continuation of the series, blending familiar elements with new twists. While some moments raised eyebrows, the overall reception has been overwhelmingly positive, with fans eagerly awaiting the next installment. Whether you’re here for Sebastian’s devilish charm, Ciel’s cunning schemes, or the sheer absurdity of Soma’s elephant entrance, this episode delivers.

As one fan perfectly put it: “AAAAA IT JUST KEEPS GETTING BETTER.” And honestly? We couldn’t agree more.

Rating: 9/10 – A must-watch for Black Butler fans, packed with drama, humor, and just the right amount of chaos.

What did you think of the episode? Drop your thoughts in the comments!